CooperVision, Inc. v. Ciba Vision Corp., 2007 WL 2408881(E.D.Tex. Aug 21, 2007) (NO. 2:06CV00149RHC, 9:06CV00260RHC)
Judge: Ron Clark
Holding: Objections to Memorandum and Order Construing Claim Terms DENIED
Defendant appealed Judge Hines' Markman ruling. Judge Clark stated simply:
Judge Hines recited the correct standard and made specific findings on each of the claim terms at issue in a detailed thirty-three (33) page order. CIBA agrees that Judge Hines reached the constructions “after careful consideration of the parties' respective positions.” CIBA simply disagrees with the conclusions reached by Judge Hines. After reviewing his findings, under the circumstances of this case, the court cannot conclude that Judge Hine's decision was clearly erroneous or contrary to law.